Chapter 2Mathematical Reasoningslides.en.pdf:114-118

Logically Valid Inference

Syllogisms and the rules that preserve truth

Def 3.3SyllogismDef 3.5Modus ponens
Concept

A logically valid inference preserves truth. If the premises are true,
the conclusion must be true too.

The classic example is modus ponens:

PPQQ\frac{P \quad P \Rightarrow Q}{Q}

Other inference rules:
- Modus tollens: from PQP \Rightarrow Q and ¬Q\neg Q, conclude ¬P\neg P.
- Hypothetical syllogism: from PQP \Rightarrow Q and QRQ \Rightarrow R, conclude PRP \Rightarrow R.

A syllogism is a logical argument with two premises and a conclusion. The
Greek tradition (Aristotle) formalized many of these — Barbara, Celarent, etc.

In modern logic, syllogisms are special cases of predicate logic with
universal statements.

Multiple representations are possible: unary s(s(o))s(s(o)), binary 1010, decimal 33, Roman III — all the same number.

Historical Note: Representations of Numbers

Before we had positional decimal (Hindu-Arabic) numbers, cultures represented quantities with one mark per unit — the unary representation. Tallies on bones, sticks, and cave walls going back ~8,000-10,000 years (the oldest known tally is the Ishango bone, ~20,000 BCE) used this idea. Even today we use unary in music ('four beats' = ♩ ♩ ♩ ♩), in protocol headers (e.g. a run-length encoding prefix), and in formal logic via the successor function s(n)s(n). Unary is theoretically simplest because there is exactly one rule: 'count another unit'.

Practice — score 100% to advance
Multiple choice
Q1
What is modus ponens?
Q2
What does it mean for an inference to be 'valid'?
Q3
Modus tollens: from PQP \Rightarrow Q and … conclude ¬P\neg P.
Q4
Hypothetical syllogism combines which two?
Q5
Is 'modus ponens' a fallacy?
Q6
Why is unary representation sometimes called 'the simplest'?
Loading…